Austrian, French and Italian delegations are to oppose cultivated-meat manufacturing on the upcoming assembly of EU agriculture ministers happening subsequent week.

In a letter to the Council of Ministers, the nations described the trade as “a risk to main farm-based approaches”.

In addition they mentioned it endangered “real meals manufacturing strategies which might be the very coronary heart of the European farming mannequin”.

“We recall that the EU has by no means delivered any authorisation on animal merchandise primarily based on cell cultivation strategies to date,” the delegations added.

“Therefore, a clear, science-based and complete strategy is important to evaluate the event of synthetic cell-based meat manufacturing, which in our view doesn’t represent a sustainable various to main farm-based manufacturing.”

The delegations of Czechia, Cyprus, Hungary, Luxembourg, Lithuania, Malta, Romania and Slovakia have supported the argument.

The be aware additionally argues cultivated meals manufacturing “raises many questions that must be completely mentioned between the member states, the Fee, stakeholders and most of the people”, earlier than it may be thought-about a viable methodology for producing meals.

A few of the questions proposed embrace easy methods to assure the security of lab-grown meat and easy methods to “stop the creation of monopolies or oligopolies on the meals market”.

The doc additionally raises considerations over the “actual carbon footprint” of cultivated, and whether or not the method gives higher animal welfare requirements.

In an announcement despatched to Simply Meals, Alex Holst, senior coverage supervisor from the choice proteins non-profit, the Good Meals Institute Europe, mentioned: “This non-binding assertion spreads misinformation about cultivated meat and undermines Europe’s world-leading regulatory system.

“The EU’s Horizon programme and nations like Germany, Spain and the Netherlands have already invested in cultivated meat, recognising its potential to enhance meals safety, scale back emissions, and fulfill rising demand for meat.

“Overhauling the gold customary Novel Meals regulatory course of now’s utterly pointless, and dangers stopping the EU from taking a number one position on this sector – simply as the USA and China put money into cultivated meat to spice up their economies and create future-proof jobs.”

In an interview with European information website Euractiv, a diplomat described the motion as “extremely exaggerated and untimely”.

“It’s a sector that doesn’t but exist, at this level it’s about innovation in a lab. Suppressing this now solely hinders the form of innovation that’s exactly essential for sustainability,” they mentioned.

The be aware marks a brand new push in opposition to cultivated meat from Italy. The nation had its ban the manufacture, sale and import of the product authorised by lawmakers final November.

Whereas the invoice has been accepted by the nationwide Chamber of Deputies, it nonetheless requires the ultimate blessing from the EU.

Singapore, the US and Israel are the one nations worldwide to have authorised the manufacturing of cultivated meat to date.

Israel joined this checklist earlier this week after giving the inexperienced gentle to Aleph Farms for its cultivated beef product, Petit Steak.

In 2020, Eat Simply’s subsidiary Good Meat obtained regulatory approval for its cultivated hen in Singapore.

Eat Simply and one other US group, Upside Meals, gained approval to provide and market their cultivated hen within the US market final yr.

Join our day by day information round-up!

Give your online business an edge with our main trade insights.